tests/15-07-24_melco
 
Test.
Deutsch English|

Melco HA-N1A, Part 1

25.02.2016 // Dirk Sommer

Those of us with a long experience in hi-fi (and the old age that inevitably comes with it) may dimly remember the name Melco. They will associate it with a rather interesting turntable from Japan that caused quite a stirin the 1970-ies. Driven by a Pabst motor that was originally designed to be used in Swiss tape machines andwith a modular setup it certainly served as an inspiration for many other heavy mass-loaded designs, like the Audiolabor Konstant, for example. This turntable was the brainchild of one Makoto Maki from whose name derived the name of his company Maki Electronic Laboratory Company, or short: 'Melco'. After that start in hi-fi, Melco changed its direction slightly and went on to design and manufacture other electronics. Probably better know under their brand name Buffalo, they grew into being Japan's largest manufacturer of computer peripherals and a world-market leader for network routers, Ethernet switches and of course storage solutions. But Mr Maki never gave up his love for music and hi-fi and so naturally was on board when the new trend of computer hi-fi emerged. Dissatisfied with the sound quality of his own private hires audio system he then asked his engineers to come up with ideas for a truly audiophile NAS drive. This was the start of a new project that led to the development of the Melco N1A and N1Z and brought back the Melco brand.

The OLED display does not inform about the owners favourite drink but about the song currently playing. Other information given includes the connected DAC as well as sampling rate and codec of the current file
The OLED display does not inform about the owners favourite drink but about the song currently playing. Other information given includes the connected DAC as well as sampling rate and codec of the current file

The development project had two main goals: to create a digital music system that offered the best sound quality possible and that was very easy to set up and to use. The user was supposed to be able to use the system without ever having to connect a computer – not even when importing files or when making a backup of the stored data. To make this possible, the Melco comes with dedicated USB ports for import, backup and expansion of storage space. To meet audiophile expectations, the Melco system engineered from the ground up as a true hifi component, not as a computer. This can be seen in the way the Melco uses its ethernet ports but as I will concentrate on the use together with a USB DAC. I will leave a more detailed description of that to my colleague Roland Dietl in the secondpart of this review. Other efforts to improve the sound performance can be seen in the use of a 'Audio-grade Ultra-low Jitter Data Clock', the robust metal chassis with a massive aluminium front plate and the bespoke resonance-dampening feet courtesy of TAOC. An industry-grade power supply rated at 60W and elaborately suspended mounts for the hard disk drives complete the picture. But the true secret lies in the way that data is being handled provided for output. For this, Melco use their own software that is partially based on a heavily customized version of the Twonky UPnP server and ensures a bit-perfect transport of data with the least possible amount of jitter.

The four symbols on the right tell us that a network connection to the router has been established and that there is no player connected to the Melco. Instead, a USB DAC is receiving data in the form of a DSD file. Usage of available storage space can be seen below the IP address
The four symbols on the right tell us that a network connection to the router has been established and that there is no player connected to the Melco. Instead, a USB DAC is receiving data in the form of a DSD file. Usage of available storage space can be seen below the IP address

The N1A unit that I had received from Melco's German distributor, G8 & friends, came with a pre-configured wireless nano router from TP-Link (TL-WR702N). After connecting this to the ethernet port marked 'LAN' on the back of the N1A I ended up with a private wireless network that I could connect my mobile device in order to use my control app of choice. Melco recommends a number of apps to use with their devices. Unfortunately, my first generation iPad is still on iOS 5 so I ended up using my trusty Linn Kinsky app which worked like a charm. The unit had come with some gigabytes of music on the disks already so I was able to jump right in. And because that collection included a few rock gems in DSD – Tubular Bells, Dire Straits, Stevie Ray Vaughan, The Band or Pink Floyd to name just a few – my first encounter with the N1A proved to be an acoustically very satisfying trip down memory lane. But to say that I had never heard these old favouritesof mine as good as then is not really saying much at all because I never had a chance to listen to them in this format. So this was certainly a good start but there was no way around it, I needed my usual selection of music for testing. To copy this onto the Melco turned out to be no challenge at all, neither over the Wi-Fi nor via a USB pen drive. And those tracks too sounded amazing when played from the N1A. To be able to judge about how good this setup actually sounds I then went on comparing it directly with the iMac that I use for music.

But this of course not only meant comparing the Melco to the Apple computer, as the software player used has at least the same influence on the over-all sound quality as does the hardware. For the first song I used the 2.6 (4500) version of Amarra Symphony. The iMac still runs on OS X 10.9.5 and because it is a stable, reliable and well-sounding environment for all my music editing and playback needs I don't intend to change that any time soon! But that certainly wasn't the reason why Ravi Shankar's 'East Meets West' sounded noticably more crisp and clear when played from the Melco. There seemed to be a better flow to the music, and an enormous soundstage opened up in front of me. In comparison, the performance from the iMac/Amarra combination was more constricted, even a little listless, maybe. It also presented a slightly richer bass but personally I would prefer the airy and joyous enthusiasm ofthe Melco any day.


  • Melco S100

    Thanks to Melco, I haven't played my ripped CDs and high-resolution audio files on a computer for years. In the meantime, the Japanese digital specialists offer not only various music servers and network players, but also a switch optimized for audio applications. In my wife's chain located in the living room an N1A 60HA/2 provides the data, while in the my listening room it's an N1Z 60HA/2 taking over the job, and for ripping CDs…
    19.06.2020
  • Melco S100

    Ich habe es Melco zu verdanken, dass ich meine gerippten CDs und hochaufgelösten Audio-Files schon seit Jahren nicht mehr per Computer abspiele. Inzwischen umfasst das Angebot der japanischen Digital-Spezialisten nicht nur diverse Musikserver und Netzwerkspieler, sondern auch ein für Audio-Anwendungen optimiertes Switch. In der Kette meiner Gattin im Wohnzimmer liefert ein N1A 60HA/2 die Daten, im Arbeitszimmer ist es N1Z 60HA/2, und zum Rippen von CDs benutzen die Kollegen und ich das D100-Laufwerk, unseren sogenannten…
    21.02.2020
  • AudiophileOptimizer – Teil 2

    Ich habe es in Teil 1 meines Berichts über AudiophileOptimizer bereits angekündigt: Die Klangqualität eines Windows Systems lässt sich noch erheblich steigern, wenn wir auf eine Version von Windows Server als Betriebssystem zurückgreifen. Wir begeben uns jetzt zu den Wurzeln von AudiophileOptimizer. Die Idee von Philipp Hobi, ein Windows Server Betriebssystem anstelle des üblichen Windows Client Betriebssystems zu verwenden, war vor einigen Jahren revolutionär und ist auch heute noch zumindest außergewöhnlich. Die dahinterstehende Überlegung ist…
    11.10.2019
  • AudiophileOptimizer – Teil 1

    Meist dauert es mehrere Wochen, um einen Testbericht zu schreiben, manchmal auch länger – dann wird unser Chefredakteur unruhig. Am Bericht über AudiophileOptimizer, eine Programm-Suite zur Optimierung von Windows-Betriebssystemen für die Musikwiedergabe, habe ich mehrere Monate gearbeitet und unseren Chefredakteur in die Verzweiflung getrieben! Neue Betriebssystem-Versionen und die erst vor kurzem veröffentlichte Version 3.0 von AudiophileOptimizer während des Testzeitraums haben immer wieder zu Verzögerungen geführt. Beta-Versionen wollte ich nicht vorstellen, und alles sollte weitgehend ausgetestet…
    08.10.2019
  • Melco D100-B

    Laufwerke zum Konvertieren von CDs in Computer-Formate sind daheim längst etabliert. Jetzt bringt Melco ein neues externes optisches Laufwerk auf den Markt, das nicht nur im Zusammenspiel mit den hauseigenen Musik-Servern bemerkenswert ist. Seitdem Computer-Hifi eine Rolle spielt, besitzt beinahe jeder von uns ein geeignetes Laufwerk zum Rippen von CDs. Viele Musik-Server, auf denen die konvertierten CDs neben hoch aufgelösten Musik-Dateien gesammelt werden, sind mit einem integrierten Laufwerk zum Wandeln auf Flac, Wav, AIFF oder…
    14.12.2018
  • Audirvana Plus 3 – ein Nachtrag

    In dieser Zeit machen auch Entwickler mal Ferien, weshalb es schon mal etwas länger dauert, bis alle gewünschten Informationen eintreffen. Audirvana-Chef Damien Plisson hat nun ein paar Fakten nachgereicht. Aber das wäre noch kein Grund für einen Nachtrag. Er schlug auch eine klanglich vielversprechende Variante für den Einsatz seiner Software vor. Im Bericht über den Audirvana Plus 3 für Windows konnten Sie nur die technischen Mindestanforderungen für die Hardware finden, auf der der Music Player…
    27.07.2018

Wir nutzen Cookies auf unserer Website. Einige von ihnen sind essenziell für den Betrieb der Seite, während andere uns helfen, diese Website und die Nutzererfahrung zu verbessern (Tracking Cookies). Sie können selbst entscheiden, ob Sie die Cookies zulassen möchten. Bitte beachten Sie, dass bei einer Ablehnung womöglich nicht mehr alle Funktionalitäten der Seite zur Verfügung stehen.