tests/20-03-18_finite
 
Test.
Deutsch English|

Finite Elemente Pagode Edition MKII

02.12.2020 // Wolfgang Kemper

Luis Fernandes spent a lot of time to find out whether the material he used for the old Pagode shelves is still the best possible option or another material would do a better job by offering acoustic advantages. It became apparent that the component shelves offered potential for optimisation, and that to a considerable extent. The shelves of the old Pagode featured a sandwich design with two eight millimetre thick MDF layers, between which a silicone layer, enclosed by two thin layers of paper, took care of the damping. All round the shelf had a glued edging. These shelves were comparatively heavy and caused a high grade of damping. The sandwich construction of the MKII shelves has now been improved to such an extent that an ultra-light polymer honeycomb core between two thin layers of MDF assume the absorbing task. This results in an improved resonance behaviour and leads to less damping thanks to reduced energy storage. Compared with silicone, the new material features a very good absorption capability, but avoids its softness correlating with a certain degree of marshyness. With regard to sound, the new honeycomb sandwich leads to less musically relevant energy dissipation, and therefore to more dynamics. I learned this not only from the technical explanations of Luis Fernandes, but when comparing the two stands I could easily perceive considerably increased fine dynamics and other positive acoustic effects without knowing the technical background, i.e. the new material mix, at the time of listening. For owners of an old Pagode, as I am one of them, the obvious way to go would be to replace the old component shelves with the new ones. However, this thought can be well dropped, as the whole resonance damping system of the old Pagode wouldn’t any longer work.

The four individually tuned resonators are embedded horizontally in the H-bracing of each level. Their stainless steel retainers are visible on the frame’s inside
The four individually tuned resonators are embedded horizontally in the H-bracing of each level. Their stainless steel retainers are visible on the frame’s inside

For the listening test, the Soul music server preamp was placed on the upper of the four levels of the old Pagode rack, while each of the two lower ones accomodated for my Air Tight mono tube power amplifiers respectively. In the compartment above, i.e. below the Soul, the Soul E power amplifier awaited its later use. We started our listening journey with the track Sotho Blue by Abdullah Ibrahim & Ekaya, which, like all the other musical material, originated from the Soul’s internal hard drive. In the first step we only moved the Soul to the new Pagode MKII, while the Air Tights remained in place. The gain in detail resolution and spatial imaging was striking. The snare drum and also the cymbals sounded more nuanced, colourful and sculptural. All the more I was struck by the unmistakable gain in dynamics. So the attacking entry of the wind instruments with their saxophones and the trombone, which were so appealingly captured on this album, manifested themselves much more ardently in their lush timbres. And when the mono power amps switched their location onto the same levels in the new Pagode stand, this brought a distinct qualitative leap as well, and this time particularly in terms of coherence. Although the acoustic image now presented itself more closed in a positive sense, the extra bit of detail resolution could not be ignored. This especially proved true for the powerful, low registers of the bass, whose strings now intoned with even more contour and grip.

This graph shows the effect of a resonator tuned to 512 Hertz – without it on the left, with it on the right
This graph shows the effect of a resonator tuned to 512 Hertz – without it on the left, with it on the right

The differences between the two Pagode stands were of similar nature when it came to Luigi Boccherini's "Sonata for Violoncello in G major", played by Bruno Cocset and Les Basses Réunies, although this piece of music appeared to be much calmer and more solemn than the jazz piece. With the new Pagode, the finely detailed lower registered string instruments not only became more dynamic, slender and orderly, but also depicted a pleasantly coherent atmospheric picture throughout the fundatmental range, much more adequate to the instrumentation in play. No doubt, this was musically convincing, and above all it was more exciting to listen and immerse oneself in the music. When we transferred the Soul music server together with the Soul E power amp instead of the Air Tights from the old onto the new Pagode in the same way, the improvement was exactly identical, but in some aspects a little less pronounced. Actually, the Soul E retails at about a sixth of the Air Tights, or let’s put it this way: The Soul and Soul E combo costs less than the tested Pagode MKII. But, to draw the conclusion from this aspect that such an investment in an equipment support is somewhat disproportionate may prove fatally deceptive. Because the advantages heard were not small and should increase the musical enjoyment in the long run, as simply more incidents happen within the music. This quickly became even more obvious as soon as we swapped the Soul and Soul E back onto the old Pagode. The backfall was even more brute than I expected. As sad as it might be: The music always seemed tedious and tired. And so did the suspense and pithiness of the vocals in the Ween song "Buenas Tardes Amigo", which the MKII had just mapped out in a captivating and poignant way, get lost as well.


  • Wilson Benesch Tessellate Ti-S

    Im September schilderte ich Ihnen meine ersten Erfahrungen mit einem seriennahen Wilson Benesch Tessellate Ti-S und kündigte den Test des Serienmodells an. Das traf bald darauf ein, doch einige Messen, eine mehrtägige Aufnahme und – ich gebe es zu – ein kurzer Urlaub verzögerten bis vor kurzem die Beschäftigung mit diesem faszinierenden Tonabnehmer. Wenn es so gekommen wäre, wie ich angenommen hatte, dass mir Krey Baumgartl von IAD, dem deutschen Wilson-Benesch-Vertrieb, nämlich einen Tonabnehmer frisch…
    07.01.2025
  • Dan Clark Audio Noire X

    Lange Zeit war ich fest davon überzeugt, dass offene Kopfhörer geschlossenen prinzipiell überlegen sind. Erst der Dan Clark Audio Stealth hat diese Überzeugung erschüttert. Großen Anteil an dessen nahezu perfektem Klang dürfte das Acoustic-Metamaterial-Tuning-System haben. Das hat Dan Clark nun auch in den deutlich günstigeren Noire X integriert. Dass ich den Klang meines Stealth nur als „nahezu perfekt“ beschreibe, liegt allein daran, dass dessen offene Variante, der Expanse, in einigen wenigen Teildisziplinen wie etwa der…
    03.01.2025
  • EAhibrid PureDC-B1/H, EAL 2000/1000 und EAU 2000/1000 – Teil 2

    EAhibrids Gleichstromnetzteile auf Akkubasis stellten in Teil 1 des Tests bereits ihre Fähigkeiten unter Beweis. Im zweiten Teil des Tests beschäftige ich mich mit EAhibrids Filterkabeln und möchte herausfinden, welche Synergien gemeinsam mit den Netzteilen entstehen. An meinem Digital-Analog-Wandler, Roon-Core-Server und Switch spielen bereits seit einigen Tagen EAhibrids Netzteile. Jetzt werde ich das System um die LAN- und USB-Filterkabel ergänzen. Nachdem ich mich mit Karen Elsons „Wonder Blind“ eingehört habe, bleibe ich zunächst bei diesem…
    27.12.2024
  • EAhibrid PureDC-B1/H, EAL 2000/1000 und EAU 2000/1000 – Teil 1

    Der heutige Test ist zweierlei Hinsicht etwas Besonderes. EAhibrid aus Taiwan produziert Gleichstrom-Akkunetzteile. In dieser Form macht das kein weiterer Hersteller – Besonderheit Nummer 1. Hifistatement testet als erstes deutsches Magazin überhaupt EAhibrid – Besonderheit 2. Neben den Netzteilen gehören auch USB- und LAN-Filterkabel zum Test. Dem aufmerksamen Besucher der High End dürfte EAhibrid bereits aufgefallen sein. Die 2021 gegründete Marke hatte 2022 dort ihren ersten Auftritt. Inzwischen hat sich ihrer mit Audioware ein österreichischer…
    23.12.2024
  • PS Audio Aspen FR5 Lautsprecher

    PS Audio ist seit vielen Jahren für seine herausragenden D/A-Wandler, Verstärker und Stromregeneratoren bekannt. Es ist noch nicht allzu lange her, dass man sich dazu entschied, das Produktportfolio um eine Lautsprecher-Linie zu erweitern. Mit dem jüngsten Spross, dem Kompaktlautsprecher Aspen FR5, wird die Produktpalette nach unten abgerundet. Als PS Audio vor einigen Jahren das Top Modell Aspen FR30 auf den Markt brachte, war die Überraschung in der Szene groß, hat doch PS Audio in seiner…
    17.12.2024
  • MK Analogue MM-PH-AMP and SUT-1L

    For Markus Wierl, who calls his company – or himself? – Audio-Freak and has been dealing with audiophile music reproduction for many years, providing his customers with wide-ranging advice before making a sale is of primary importance, as can be seen from his website and his YouTube channel. Furthermore, he is much more open-minded than the author when it comes to the field of high-end. He is not much into being deterred by home cinema…
    13.12.2024

Wir nutzen Cookies auf unserer Website. Einige von ihnen sind essenziell für den Betrieb der Seite, während andere uns helfen, diese Website und die Nutzererfahrung zu verbessern (Tracking Cookies). Sie können selbst entscheiden, ob Sie die Cookies zulassen möchten. Bitte beachten Sie, dass bei einer Ablehnung womöglich nicht mehr alle Funktionalitäten der Seite zur Verfügung stehen.